Home About   RSS Feed

Gamification in Education: Epic Win, or Epic Fail?

By: Kristen Bourgault


Have you ever felt that each move you made in life was part of a bigger game? These days it just may be, as a trend referred to as “gamification” has swept industries as diverse as marketing, travel, and even education. While turning everything into a game sure seems like fun, it’s not as easy as it sounds. This article will explore the trend towards gamification, as well as some of its criticism.

WHAT IS GAMIFICATION?

“Games are the most elevated form of investigation.” Albert Einstein

Gamification is a strategy by which ordinary processes are infused with principles of motivation and engagement inspired by game theory. Or as Wikipedia would say, “Gamification is the use of game design techniques and mechanisms to solve problems and engage audiences.”

While games have been a popular activity throughout history, the Internet and social networking have inspired a whole new wave of players actively engaged in daily gameplay. The free, browser based virtual farm game, Farmville, boasts over 80 million active users per month as players earn virtual money and level up to compete against their friends. World of Warcraft, an online role playing game, claims 10.3 million subscribers as of November 2011, and that number continues to grow.

What is it that attracts so many people to become so deeply engaged in these virtual environments? If video games are revered as one of the most highly engaging activities of the 21st century, then shouldn’t we try to capture elements from video games, and apply them to teaching and learning?

GAMIFICATION TO IMPROVE LEARNING

Gamification, at a meaningful level, requires a complete restructuring of activities, assessments and feedback mechanisms. It involves a true reworking of a course from soup to nuts. Many game developers would also insist that it cannot be achieved without a trained game developer at the helm of the decision-making process. The very best and most engaging games employ a strong narrative structure to carry the participants through the game.

Game design isn’t just a technological craft. It’s a twenty-first-century way of thinking and leading. And gameplay isn’t just a pastime. It’s a twenty-first-century way of working together to accomplish real change.” Jane McGonigal

What elements of video games can you leverage in your own course design in order to increase learner engagement and motivation? Jane McGonigal, a leading researcher and voice in video game theory, breaks it down to the essentials: “When you strip away the genre differences and the technological complexities, all games share four defining traits: a goal, rules, a feedback system, and voluntary participation.”

But wait! Isn’t that basic course design right there? Identifying a straightforward and achievable goal, developing rules for conduct, behavior, and progress through a course, setting up your mechanisms for feedback and assessment, and finally, opening the doors to all of the ‘voluntary participants.’ If these are the components we expect to include in the courses we develop, is it too far of a stretch to imagine how gamification might be utilized to create a more engaging, learner-centered experience?

Games address things we already know improve education – increased collaboration, problem-based learning, constructive feedback, mentoring. You can utilize these teaching strategies without having to transform your entire course into Candyland. However, keeping an eye on the methods used to engage players in games and perhaps even playing a few yourself, can only open up new possibilities in structure, feedback and pace for your courses.

THE CHEAPENING OF GAMIFICATION

Is gamification really the magical process that so many believe it to be? Many critics would argue against it, saying this process merely cheapens and distracts from the learner’s experience.

Look around you – elements of video games are creeping into many of your daily activities. Have you booked a flight recently on Trip Advisor? Commented on a Huffington Post article? New ways of “earning badges” and “unlocking achievements” are cropping up every day. But does the ability to earn a badge automatically increase our engagement in an activity?

Game designer and consultant Margaret Robertson doesn’t think so. In a recent blog post speaking out against the term ‘gamification’, Robertson wrote, “What we’re currently terming gamification is in fact the process of taking that thing that is least essential to games and representing it as the core of the experience. Points and badges have no closer a relationship to games than they do to websites and fitness apps and loyalty cards. They’re great tools for communicating progress and acknowledging effort, but neither points nor badges in any way constitute a game.”

“Gamification is the wrong word for the right idea. The word for what’s happening at the moment is pointsification. There are things that should be pointsified. There are things that should be gamified. There are things that should be both. There are many, many things that should be neither.” Margaret Robertson

You may be tempted to jump on board and trade your grades in for badges and call it a game. But this simple act doesn’t dramatically change the learner’s experience. Take some time to really understand what makes a good game great. Create a compelling narrative to pull your students through the course. Set up mentoring and collaboration opportunities such as those you encounter in games to enable learners to share what they know. And frequently chime in with feedback. Use those badges to chart progress, but meaningful instructor feedback is what will truly propel the learner forward.

“Gamification, by contrast, doesn’t rely on internal motivation. Instead, it’s using the oldest tricks in the book: providing instantaneous feedback, egging on the competition, and rewarding even tiny steps of progress. Gamification assumes that the player isn’t especially motivated – at least at the beginning – and then provides barrels of incentives to ramp up that motivation.” Elizabeth Corcoran

CONCLUSION

Do video games have much to teach us about how to create dynamic and engaging environments? Most definitely! There is so much we can learn about motivation from game theory. But at the same time we must also approach gamification with caution, understanding that it is a complex, time consuming process and not the quick fix some of us may be looking for.

In my next article I will talk more about that process, by sharing a game I created to infuse fun and adventure into a traditionally boring internal technology training workshop.

You have unlocked the “I read this article” achievement.

 

RESOURCES

Cashmore, P. (2010). Farmville surpasses 80 million users. Retrieved from http://mashable.com/2010/02/20/farmville-80-million-users/

Corcoran, E. (2010). The ‘gamification’ of education. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/2010/10/28/education-internet-scratch-technology-gamification_2.html

Gamification. (2012). Retrieved from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gamification

Lee, J. J. & Hammer, J. (2011). Gamification in Education: What, How, Why Bother? Academic Exchange Quarterly, 15(2).

McGonigal, J. (2011). Reality is Broken: Why Games Make Us Better and How They Can Change the World. New York, NY: Penguin Press.

Robertson, M. (2010, October 6). Can’t play, won’t play. [Blog entry]. Retrieved from http://www.hideandseek.net/2010/10/06/cant-play-wont-play/

Leave a Reply

From Pilot to Production: Implementing a Social Media Learning Tool in Online Science Courses

By: Frances Rowe
dandelion

This article tells the story of how implementing a connectivist tool called VoiceThread (VT) enhanced Read More »

4 Easy Steps to Prepare and Use OER Materials in Your Next Course

By: Sarah Dampier
free the textbook

Image credit: opensourceway

 

The rising cost of higher education continues to draw national attention, with the cost of textbooks playing a role in these conversations. In fact, CNN included “save money with open-source textbooks” in Read More »

8 Things You Should Know before Using Social Media in Your Course

By: Jennifer Rafferty
computer keyboard

 

The 2014 Horizon Report for Higher Education has cited the growing ubiquity of social media as one of the fast trends that will be a Read More »

QU Online Instructional Designer Receives Quality Matters Course Recognition

By: Jennifer Rafferty
neidig

We are very pleased to announce that Christopher Neidig, senior instructional designer and project manager for QU Online and part-time instructor in the School of Communications, has received a Quality Matters seal of approval for the course, ICM508 – Media Production. Read More »

Alternate Credentialing Forum -Thursday, June 12, 2014 at UMASS Boston

By: Jennifer Rafferty
badge alliance , examples of badges

UMASS Boston’s Center for Innovation and Excellence in eLearning (CIIE), College of Advancing and Profession Studies (CAPS) will host an Alternate Credentialing

Forum at the Corcoran-Jennison building (next to the Bayside Expo Center) on 150 Mount Vernon Street, Boston, MA.

The event is free to public but spaces are limited so Read More »

Getting the Word Out about Self-regulated Learning Interventions

By: Jennifer Rafferty
self-regulated learning word cloud

Frances Rowe, Director of Instructional Design and Technology Support, and Jennifer Rafferty, Associate Director of Instructional Design, recently presented at the NERCOMP Instructional Design Symposium in  Read More »

Tiny but Mighty: Learning Management System Is Home to Even the Most Out-of-this-World Users

By: Jennifer Rafferty
blackboardians

Who would have thought that a learning management system could be a welcoming and cozy space?  QU Online instructional designers have discovered that their Blackboard 9 LMS can reach beyond the traditional application Read More »

Textbooks Are the Tipping Point: How Open Educational Resources Change the Landscape

By: Sarah Dampier
mason jar with water falling off a chaira

 

As faculty, there is no doubt that you spend a great deal of time thinking about how you can help your students reach the finish line of graduation and successful careers thereafter. To achieve this, you likely weigh options concerning course materials, course structure,  Read More »

My Top 3 Picks from the Digital Media Learning Conference 2014

By: Jennifer Rafferty
creative commons logo

Sometimes you find yourself so inspired by a learning experience that you just have to write home about it!  My postcard from the Digital Media Learning Conference 2014 will give you a glimpse Read More »

E3 Engagement, Empowerment & E-learning Call for Proposals

By: Jennifer Rafferty
Engagement Empowerment E-learning Call for Proposals

How Do We Love Online and Distance Education? Let Us Count the Ways…

By: Jennifer Rafferty
elearning hear

Designed by Dan Shpak

Still looking for a way to celebrate Valentine’s Day 2014?  Or have you sworn off this holiday for good? Think again…The instructional designers at QU Online  Read More »

The Essential Instructional Designer: The Job e-Learning Can’t Live Without, Part 2

By: Jennifer Rafferty
instructional designer word cloud

Last week , we introduced you to three talented instructional designers who work in the field of e-Learning in higher education.  This week, In part II of the blog, our featured guests will conclude the discussion by talking about some of the Read More »

The Essential Instructional Designer: The Job e-Learning Can’t Live Without

By: Jennifer Rafferty
instructional design word cloud

Instructional design is not a new profession, but it has been garnering well-deserved attention in the past decade thanks to the growth of online education. O*Net Online, the nation’s primary source of occupational information, reported in 2013 that the instructional design Read More »

Blogging from Abroad: 12 Considerations for Faculty Led Courses and Programs

By: Jennifer Rafferty
albert schweitzer institute guatemala blog

Study abroad is on the rise once again.  Faculty led short-term programs are also increasing in numbers and so is our ability to access the Internet from just about anywhere in the world.   Staying connected with students through blogging while they travel and observing them Read More »

Looking Back: 8 Tools We Loved to Use in 2013

By: Jennifer Rafferty

What tools and applications made your life easier in 2013? Well, the instructional design team at QU Online gathered together to talk about their favorite applications for both professional and personal use during 2013 and they came up with this nifty list. Read More »

5 Essential Building Blocks for an Online Course

By: Sarah Dampier
wooden blocks

For traditional classroom instructors, successfully developing an online course for the first time can be daunting. Read More »

Are We Heading Back to Grunting?

By: Judy Falaro
chisels

“We are living in a world that is changing so quickly that as I sit here writing this, I feel as if I’m chiseling this in stone.”

The other day I read a story about a professor who loved to give his classes the gift of pop quizzes. He would assign material and was thoughtful enough Read More »

QU Online Instructional Designers Team Up with Quinnipiac Faculty to Receive Quality Matters Course Recognition

By: Jennifer Rafferty
quality matters seal of approval

2013 has been a productive year for the instructional design team at QU Online!   Our instructional designers have been collaborating with Quinnipiac faculty to achieve the Quality Matters seal of approval for Read More »

Diving Into Developing a YouTube Channel

By: Frances Rowe
bio statistics logo

Well, it was more like treading water…

If your hope is to have publicly facing instructional videos on YouTube, this article will provide you with practical advice on how to produce a channel that your institution is likely to endorse. Read More »

The E-volution Conference – Registration is now open!

By: Jennifer Rafferty
evolutionregistration

Read More »

I’m Wondering: Is This the Way Columbus Felt?

By: Judy Falaro
Columbus statue

For the past few years, I have been so excited as the world of education and the world of technology have become more like a family than just neighbors.  I’m not talking about the move from desktops Read More »

The Best of 2012: 5 Books for Instructional Design and Technology Mavens

By: Frances Rowe
yellow ball with smile face

 

The instructional design and technology team at QU Online sought out to find the best books in our field from 2012. If you have a favorite, please Read More »

Are We Overloading Our Plates When Choosing from the Tempting Buffet of Web 2.0 Tools?

By: Judy Falaro
Web 2.0 teacher

Our world and classrooms have become sleek, simple and high tech or complex, confusing and bloated with high tech.  Your view may depend on your age, background, exposure to and comfort level with the dazzling array of web tools we have at our disposal.  Read More »

A Space for All Voices: The Online Discussion Forum, by Professor Margaret Goralski

By: Jennifer Rafferty
man and woman profile

This week I have the pleasure of presenting guest blogger, Professor Margaret Goralski, from the School of Business at Quinnipiac University.  Recently, I attended a workshop where Professor Goralski presented on her experience using the discussion forum in her online courses.  Read More »

Game Design at Quinnipiac and Beyond Part II: A Conversation with Professor Ira Fay

By: Dan Shpak

Last week, we provided an interview about gamification with Greg Garvey, the Director of the Game Design and Development Program at Quinnipiac University.  This week, we talk to Ira Fay, an Assistant Professor of Game Design & Development in Quinnipiac University’s Visual and Performing Arts Department.  Ira tells us his thoughts on game design and education. Read More »

Game Design at Quinnipiac and Beyond: A Conversation with Professor Greg Garvey

By: Jennifer Rafferty
gregory garvey

Professor Gregory Garvey

The instructional design team at QU Online is very excited about the recent inception in 2011 of the Game Design and Development Program at Quinnipiac University.  Read More »

Online Occupational Therapy Course Receives Quality Matters’ Seal of Approval

By: Jennifer Rafferty
quality matters logo

“Evidence Based Practice in Occupational Therapy,” a course developed and taught online by professor Catherine Meriano,program director of the online Masters of Science in Occupational Therapy in the School of Health Sciences, with Read More »

4 Keys to Curbing the Cost of Course Materials

By: Frances Rowe
open education resources

According to the College Board, students pay $1213.00 a year on average for books and supplies. A recent survey of 1095 undergraduates released by the U.S. Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) found that 70% of students had forgone the textbook at least once because the price was too high. How will students do in the course without the required materials? Read More »

Flipping Your Course: Making Your On-ground Lectures Available Online

By: Chris Neidig
camtasia studio and itunes logos

Getting students to retain information from your lectures can be a difficult challenge.  Traditional class lectures in a hybrid course don’t always ensure that students will understand key concepts. Integrating multimedia into a course Read More »

The Blackboardians Have Landed: Infusing Game Mechanics Into Traditional Web-based Training

By: Kristen Bourgault

Game theory has recently been gaining momentum in the field of instructional design, as it is commonly believed that the elements which motivate people to play games could be applied to learning situations in order to engage students. Theoretically it sounds wonderful – but can it be applied to real life learning situations?

Last fall I was charged with training my colleagues to prepare them for an upgrade of our learning management system. This sounded like a tedious task and one sure to make me an enemy within the group. How could I generate some fun and excitement around this routine training instead of becoming a source of frustration and obligation for my colleagues?
Read More »